I Don’t Really Need Another [Insert Obligatory Gift Here]

According to Merriam-Webster, the word "obligation" primarily relates to matters contractual and fiscal: 

Main Entry: ob·li·ga·tion

1: the action of obligating oneself to a course of action (as by a promise or vow) 2a: something (as a formal contract, a promise, or the demands of conscience or custom) that obligates one to a course of action b: a debt security (as a mortgage or corporate bond) c: a commitment (as by a government) to pay a particular sum of money ; also: an amount owed under such an obligation obligations, the company went into bankruptcy> 3a: a condition or feeling of being obligated b: a debt of gratitude 4: something one is bound to do: duty, responsibility

Oooh, such fun, no? The definition itself is full of scary economic references, complete with mentions of government and bankruptcy. In fact, there is only a single word in the entire definition that feels full of positivity and light: "gratitude" (but they even wreck that with the use of "debt of...").

So I've decided that I am supposed to take this definition - indeed, this time and place in our economy - as a further sign that I need to stop with the obligatory gifts. Instead of taking something that is meant to be meaningful and schmoopy (gift-giving), and weighing it down with debt/demands/contracts...let's make a pact with everyone we love:

If it's not the very best, most perfect gift you've ever found for that person at that point in time...agree to wait until something better comes up. 

Because I'm pretty sure you didn't need that perfume anyway.

-Heather...off to send an email telling my friends and fam about the plan...

And now... The Worst Obligatory Gifts We've Ever Received

  • Mama Bite Editor Alison: "A paperweight. When is that ever appropriate?"
  • NY Editor Brianne: "When I was 19 I was dating this Lebanese guy. I think he had no clue about women and got me this huge Estée Lauder makeup kit the size of a briefcase, which would have been OK, I guess, if A) I wore makeup, or B) I was a 10-year-old."
  • Chicago Editor Daisy: "I received a cookbook for Southern-style meat. I'm a vegetarian. I also received a personalized planner from my landlord. Personalized with her name and address."
  • Editorial Assistant Erica: "My ex-boyfriend bought me a bright orange bathrobe. I don't wear orange, and even if I did, who wants an orange bathrobe? Not very sexy..."
  • SF Editor Hanah: "One Hanukkah during high school I got a crystal vase from a boyfriend's aunt. So impersonal. And an ex-boyfriend waited in my room with the lights off until I came home, so he could give me a huge apple-scented Bath & Body Works basket. Needless to say, I broke up with him soon after that."
  • Seattle Editor Jen H: "A s'mores maker in a beat-up box that, from the looks of the happy people making s'mores on it, was at least a decade old. Such an obvious regift. It was a wedding gift from my husband's 31-year-old male cousin, at least according to the cousin's mom's handwriting on the gift tag."
  • Editorial Director Jenifer: "This Christmas I got an irregularly large, silver soap dish in the shape of a shell."
  • LA Editor Molly: "All that comes to mind is this guy who had a crush on me in fourth grade. He gave me a glass unicorn figurine. I felt all weird because I didn't like him, so I shoved it in my desk, and alas...it broke."
  • Senior Editor Theresa: "I received a cockroach from an ex-boyfriend - specifically, according to him, a $20 hissing roach from Madagascar. I screamed when I opened it."
  • Daily Tip Editor Toshio: "I got an incense burner and Nag Champa for a birthday once. I don't burn incense."
Bookmark and Share
My two best friends and I have been doing this for years! We don't give gifts until the right one shows up. Christmas gifts have been given in April, and birthday gifts given 2 months early or late. I once planted bulbs to come up in the spring as a surprise birthday gift. What's SO cool about being and ADULT is we can wait for the good stuff!!!!
Trying to comment on the vegetarian thing. I would love to know why people accept the Catholic Churches definition of meat? What is the definition of meat? In all the dictionaries I have read anything in it says it is flesh. so what is flesh, could be cow, horse, pig, turtle, but no fish? What do you call the flesh of a fish if not meat? If flesh is meat, fish have flesh but is not meat even though it is flesh? C'mon now, let's put some truth here and call a spade a spade. Fish is meat just like a big juicy steak, ham, bacon or any other flesh. I would like anyone to tell me where this is wrong.
I've found that there are at least several options for dealing with unwanted gifts, in addition to what was mentioned on today's tip: 1) Try selling them on eBay or Amazon. Sometimes you can get lucky and sell it for enough money to make it worth your time. 2) Start a yard sale box. After a while you should accumulate enough unwanted gifts and unwanted items to have a yard sale. You can team up with your friends or neighbors to have a bigger yard sale that draws more of a crowd. 3) Donate to a thrift store. Most thrift stores are non-profits that serve the local community by providing low-cost items to those who can't afford much. 4) Re-gifting - I've done this before but only when appropriate (there's nothing worse than receiving a badly re-gifted item).
Jeez, most of these gifts aren't even that bad. I agree that obligatory gift-giving is wasteful, but you guys sound like snotty b*tches by whining about receiving presents that aren't good enough for you (except the hissing cockroach one)!
Our family used mygiftster this year (www.mygiftster.com). It's a free online gift list system that connects you with your family and friends. The whole idea is by sharing your list this way, you create more thoughtful gift-giving and eliminate unwanted or duplicate gifts. What I really liked about this site as opposed to other gift sites is it allows you to shop the way you want to shop — clicks or bricks — without being tied to specific e-tailers. Plus, you can print or download shopping lists to keep track of purchases. There's also a cool feature that will show you related gift suggestions available from Amazon.
Don't we all go thru this though! One, agreeing with animal-supporting friends to give a donation in their name ANYTIME DURING THE YEAR WHEN A GOOD ONE COMES UP, and, most fun of all, I have a group of about 20 "gerlfrens" who get together at least once a month to party together....right after christmas we have a game; bring any christmas presents (or others from the year!) you received and aren't going to use or hate; you put them all, wrapped, in the center of the circle then go around the circle; each person gets to choose a package and open it. If you like it, great...you can opt out of the game and keep what you have; if you want to keep playing, the ccircle goes around again and anyone who just loves SOMEONE ELSE'S gift can trade it for the one they have...and they have to do it! Again, if you end up with something you love keep it and opt out; if not, keep playing...the circle goes around until most people have SOMETHING they really like..and it is amazing how many things you didn't want that others really do want...for instance, your editor who got a paperweight.....I collecct them! (If I like them, or if they are the kind you can put a photo on the bottom and it shows thru the glass) Many of these gifts find really good homes, and it is a really fun party game....lots of laughs and funny comments, and some real competition towards the end when a few people really want what the other persons have and keep trading then losing the item again! Try it....great fun..
My extended family does a pollyanna every Christmas. We pick names at our Family Reunion in June. Family can participate as individuals, couples or the entire family. Cost is kept low and you can suggest gift ideas to the person or group who picked your name since it's not a "secret Santa." As our family has grown from generation to generation, this is a fun way for everyone to participate.
I agree totally with Kristy -- those gifts weren't that bad (the makeup and Bath & Body Works basket would be *greatly* appreciated by any of the four females in our household! The crystal vase would be cherished here as well...) and complaining about other peoples' generousity really makes you sound like... well, what SHE said. This year my husband got me the weirdest pair of slippers ever... bright pink and furry and huge furry butterflies on the front that measure a full 7.5" from wingtip to wingtip. My feet look like a frickin nightmare when I wear those slippers but wear them I do because (1) they represent the thoughtfulness of my wonderful husband and (2) they *are* nice and warm and that's really what I wanted slippers for in the first place. Nevermind the fact that everyone who sees me wearing them can't help but chuckle.... Tell you what, ladies... next time you get one of these "horrible" gifts, just send them my way. If I can't use it, I have a rather large family who would gladly take whatever it is. Then we'll ALL be happy :)
Christmas 2008 was my worst obligatory gift event. My husband, who was well intentioned, bought me several gifts that were really intended for him, and only 1 gift that was actually for me which I already knew about because I asked him to get it for me! So, here's what I got: tri-pod for a camera cordless phone (because he doesn't like the one I bought a couple of years ago) software for the computer and pearl earrings So guess which one I actually picked out?!
As the webmaster of the not-for-profit Paperweight Collectors Association of Texas, www.pcatx.org, I invite Allison to visit our site and especially read this article, http://www.pcatx.org/presentation1.html. Anyone who is a paperweight collector or lover knows and appreciates the intricacies involved in making a beautifully crafted paperweight. I'm not talking about the cheap Chinese paperweights that are worth about 25 cents. This article on antique paperweights (mid-1800s) is published by a fellow PCA Texas colleague of mine: http://www.antiquetrader.com/article/Rare_beauty_under_glass_a_look_at_f...

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <font> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <br> <img>

More information about formatting options